A homicide trial was declared a mistrial earlier this week and will have to restart early next month.
In May 2021, police arrested 28-year-old Paris Carter of Downingtown for the killing of 38-year-David Hines in Muddy Creek Township. Carter of Philadelphia is accused of killing Hines of New Castle and leaving him on the side of the road in Portersville after the two got into an argument.
During the trial on Monday, a witness in the case made a statement that was barred from being said in court. Due to the statement the defense requested a mistrial and it was granted.
A new trial is scheduled to start on December 2 with a new jury.
Carter has been incarcerated in the Butler County Prison since his arrest and is facing one charge of criminal homicide.




